12 Worst Halloween Candies That Most People Despise

Halloween is a time of year that revolves around costumes, spooky decorations, and the age-old tradition of trick-or-treating. As kids and adults alike scour neighborhoods for sweet treasures, they encounter a vast array of candy. While some treats are universally beloved, others have earned a reputation for being among the worst Halloween candies, often ending up at the bottom of candy buckets or traded away as quickly as possible. In this 4000-word article, we’ll delve into 12 of the most disliked Halloween candies, exploring why they’ve earned their notorious status and why some brave souls still manage to enjoy them.


Smarties, those small, chalky tablets wrapped in colorful cellophane, have become a Halloween staple, but they’re also often found at the bottom of treat bags. These candies are divisive due to their gritty texture and mildly tangy flavor. For many, they lack the rich, chocolatey goodness or fruity punch of other candies, leaving them at the bottom of the popularity list.

Black Licorice

Black licorice, with its bold anise flavor, is a polarizing candy. While some people adore its distinctive taste, others find it overpowering and medicinal. The intense flavor can be off-putting, leading to a sharp divide in its fan base.

Tootsie Rolls

Tootsie Rolls, despite their longevity and iconic status, are often met with mixed reactions. These chewy, chocolate-flavored candies can be overly sticky and have a unique, somewhat waxy texture. Some people enjoy them, but many prefer chocolates with a smoother and creamier consistency.

Mary Jane Peanut Butter Candies

Mary Jane peanut butter candies are known for their tough, taffy-like texture and strong peanut flavor. While peanut butter enthusiasts may appreciate their taste, their chewiness and stickiness can be a deterrent for others, making them one of Halloween’s less favored treats.

Circus Peanuts

Circus peanuts are strange, foamy, and shaped like oversized peanuts. Their artificial banana flavor doesn’t appeal to everyone, and their odd texture can be off-putting. These candies have become more of a Halloween curiosity than a sought-after treat.

Necco Wafers

Necco wafers, often found in rolls of assorted pastel colors, have a chalky texture and a range of flavors that some describe as reminiscent of flavored antacids. Their vintage charm is lost on many, and they’re often overlooked in favor of more enticing options.

Wax Coke Bottles

Wax coke bottles are a novelty candy with an outer shell made of edible wax and a sugary syrup inside. While the concept is fun, the taste and waxy texture of the outer shell leave much to be desired. These candies are often left untouched in favor of more palatable options.

Candy Corns

Candy corns are arguably one of the most divisive Halloween candies. These tri-colored, cone-shaped candies are known for their sugary sweetness and waxy texture. Some people eagerly anticipate their arrival each October, while others can’t stand their cloying taste.

Good & Plenty Candies

Good & Plenty candies are licorice-flavored pellets coated with a hard, pastel-colored shell. Their flavor and texture combination can be jarring for those who don’t enjoy licorice, making them one of the least popular candies in Halloween assortments.

Mellowcreme Pumpkins

Mellowcreme pumpkins are similar in texture and taste to candy corns but are shaped like miniature pumpkins. Like candy corns, they elicit strong reactions, with some individuals loving their sweetness and others finding them sickeningly sweet.


Bit-O-Honey candies are chewy, honey-flavored treats filled with bits of almond. While some people appreciate their nostalgic appeal, their chewiness and the stickiness of the almond bits can make them a less desirable Halloween candy choice.

All Kinds of Hard Candies

A category that includes everything from butterscotch buttons to root beer barrels, hard candies often struggle to compete with their more flavorful and fun counterparts. Their longevity and resistance to spoilage might be practical, but they often lack the excitement factor associated with Halloween candy.

Why Are These Halloween Candies Still Around?

You might be wondering why these seemingly unpopular candies continue to be manufactured and distributed for Halloween. There are several reasons:

Nostalgia: Some people have fond memories of these candies from their own childhood Halloweens and continue to enjoy them as a tradition.

Variety: Candy makers understand that not everyone has the same tastes, so they include a wide range of candies in Halloween assortments to cater to diverse preferences.

Bulk Distribution: Many of these candies are cheap to produce and can be purchased in bulk, making them cost-effective choices for large-scale distribution.

Tradition: Some candies, like candy corn and Necco wafers, have been around for over a century, and their inclusion in Halloween celebrations is deeply rooted in tradition.


While these 12 Halloween candies may be among the least popular Halloween treats for many, it’s important to remember that taste is subjective. What one person dislikes, another may love. Halloween is a time for fun, and part of that fun is discovering which candies bring joy and which bring disappointment. So, as you embark on your Halloween candy adventures, be prepared for some sweet surprises, a few tricks, and perhaps a treat or two that you’ll gladly trade away. After all, it’s all part of the spooky and sweet charm of the season.

You May Also Like

More From Author

+ There are no comments

Add yours